Skip to main content
Law

Return to Question

Notice removed Draw attention by CommunityBot
Bounty Ended with ohwilleke's answer chosen by CommunityBot
edited tags
Link
ohwilleke
ohwilleke
  • 239.6k
  • 15
  • 465
  • 825
Copy edits and tags
Source Link
feetwet ♦
feetwet ♦
  • 22.1k
  • 13
  • 87
  • 185

My school's community service policy (while ambiguous throughout the whole thing) Seems to me to discriminate against not only religions, but my religion specifically. The particular clause I'm referring to states:

Your community service project must benefit a group, organization, or person outside of your household, immediate and extended family. Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project.

(Emphasis not mine)

The particular portion of this clause, the last part; "Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project." is what I'm at ends with. The project makes a specific statement to disallow all service associated with "Churches", in the same clause it refuses to accept projects being used for other purposes.

And to add confusion to the mess, the phrase, IMHO is unnecessarily ambiguous, stating "Church-Related" instead of being specific as to what is and isn't allowed. I've asked my guidance councellorscounselors as to what is and isn't allowed in terms of this, and they said to ask my PE teacher, as they (as per stated) are in charge of the Volunteer Community Service Project (VCSP). My PE teacher told me they can clarify questions during a pre-approval phase for the project. As I understand it, that phase goes like this:

  • The student signs up for service or alerts the organazitionorganization and recievesreceives permission to perform it.
  • The student goes to their PE teacher and asks if the project can be used for the VCSP
  • The student can ask questions about the VCSP (For some reason, only if they've already prepared a project)
  • The PE teacher either approves or denies the project, citing a reason if denied.

This whole process makes no sense to me and seems completleycompletely illogical, so I figured that before I schedule any more projects that I find out if there are cassescases of similar organaztionsorganizations to my school losing similar cases to this.

Some Details

  • The school is a public school, Located in Rhode Island (United States)
  • The Project is required to graduate
  • To my knowledge, the school has never had problems with policies before
  • I am a minor

My school's community service policy (while ambiguous throughout the whole thing) Seems to me to discriminate against not only religions, but my religion specifically. The particular clause I'm referring to states

Your community service project must benefit a group, organization, or person outside of your household, immediate and extended family. Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project.

(Emphasis not mine)

The particular portion of this clause, the last part; "Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project." is what I'm at ends with. The project makes a specific statement to disallow all service associated with "Churches", in the same clause it refuses to accept projects being used for other purposes.

And to add confusion to the mess, the phrase, IMHO is unnecessarily ambiguous, stating "Church-Related" instead of being specific as to what is and isn't allowed. I've asked my guidance councellors as to what is and isn't allowed in terms of this, and they said to ask my PE teacher, as they (as per stated) are in charge of the Volunteer Community Service Project (VCSP). My PE teacher told me they can clarify questions during a pre-approval phase for the project. As I understand it, that phase goes like this:

  • The student signs up for service or alerts the organazition and recieves permission to perform it.
  • The student goes to their PE teacher and asks if the project can be used for the VCSP
  • The student can ask questions about the VCSP (For some reason, only if they've already prepared a project)
  • The PE teacher either approves or denies the project, citing a reason if denied.

This whole process makes no sense to me and seems completley illogical, so I figured that before I schedule any more projects that I find out if there are casses of similar organaztions to my school losing similar cases to this.

Some Details

  • The school is a public school, Located in Rhode Island (United States)
  • The Project is required to graduate
  • To my knowledge, the school has never had problems with policies before
  • I am a minor

My school's community service policy (while ambiguous throughout the whole thing) Seems to me to discriminate against not only religions, but my religion specifically. The particular clause I'm referring to states:

Your community service project must benefit a group, organization, or person outside of your household, immediate and extended family. Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project.

(Emphasis not mine)

The particular portion of this clause, the last part; "Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project." is what I'm at ends with. The project makes a specific statement to disallow all service associated with "Churches", in the same clause it refuses to accept projects being used for other purposes.

And to add confusion to the mess, the phrase, IMHO is unnecessarily ambiguous, stating "Church-Related" instead of being specific as to what is and isn't allowed. I've asked my guidance counselors as to what is and isn't allowed in terms of this, and they said to ask my PE teacher, as they (as per stated) are in charge of the Volunteer Community Service Project (VCSP). My PE teacher told me they can clarify questions during a pre-approval phase for the project. As I understand it, that phase goes like this:

  • The student signs up for service or alerts the organization and receives permission to perform it.
  • The student goes to their PE teacher and asks if the project can be used for the VCSP
  • The student can ask questions about the VCSP (For some reason, only if they've already prepared a project)
  • The PE teacher either approves or denies the project, citing a reason if denied.

This whole process makes no sense to me and seems completely illogical, so I figured that before I schedule any more projects that I find out if there are cases of similar organizations to my school losing similar cases to this.

Some Details

  • The school is a public school, Located in Rhode Island (United States)
  • The Project is required to graduate
  • To my knowledge, the school has never had problems with policies before
  • I am a minor
Notice added Draw attention by Travis
Bounty Started worth 100 reputation by Travis
Source Link
Travis
Travis
  • 53
  • 7

Have there ever been examples of public school's restriction of community service being unlawful?

My school's community service policy (while ambiguous throughout the whole thing) Seems to me to discriminate against not only religions, but my religion specifically. The particular clause I'm referring to states

Your community service project must benefit a group, organization, or person outside of your household, immediate and extended family. Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project.

(Emphasis not mine)

The particular portion of this clause, the last part; "Eagle Scout, Church-related or court-ordered community service hours may not be used for this Project." is what I'm at ends with. The project makes a specific statement to disallow all service associated with "Churches", in the same clause it refuses to accept projects being used for other purposes.

And to add confusion to the mess, the phrase, IMHO is unnecessarily ambiguous, stating "Church-Related" instead of being specific as to what is and isn't allowed. I've asked my guidance councellors as to what is and isn't allowed in terms of this, and they said to ask my PE teacher, as they (as per stated) are in charge of the Volunteer Community Service Project (VCSP). My PE teacher told me they can clarify questions during a pre-approval phase for the project. As I understand it, that phase goes like this:

  • The student signs up for service or alerts the organazition and recieves permission to perform it.
  • The student goes to their PE teacher and asks if the project can be used for the VCSP
  • The student can ask questions about the VCSP (For some reason, only if they've already prepared a project)
  • The PE teacher either approves or denies the project, citing a reason if denied.

This whole process makes no sense to me and seems completley illogical, so I figured that before I schedule any more projects that I find out if there are casses of similar organaztions to my school losing similar cases to this.

Some Details

  • The school is a public school, Located in Rhode Island (United States)
  • The Project is required to graduate
  • To my knowledge, the school has never had problems with policies before
  • I am a minor