Skip to main content
added 30 characters in body
Source Link

Added after edit: Is there any clause in the Constitution of California that prevents a law from attaching fines that are worth more than the actual damage that was caused by violation of the law?Has there been any such cases?
_______________________________________________________________________
The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

Added after edit: Is there any clause in the Constitution of California that prevents a law from attaching fines that are worth more than the actual damage that was caused by violation of the law?
_______________________________________________________________________
The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

Added after edit: Is there any clause in the Constitution of California that prevents a law from attaching fines that are worth more than the actual damage that was caused by violation of the law?Has there been any such cases?
_______________________________________________________________________
The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

Spelling
Link
phoog
  • 40.1k
  • 5
  • 87
  • 134

Can a person be charged above the ammountamount of damages by laws as a fine?

added 281 characters in body
Source Link

TheAdded after edit: Is there any clause in the Constitution of California that prevents a law from attaching fines that are worth more than the actual damage that was caused by violation of the law?
_______________________________________________________________________
The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

Added after edit: Is there any clause in the Constitution of California that prevents a law from attaching fines that are worth more than the actual damage that was caused by violation of the law?
_______________________________________________________________________
The jurisdiction is : USA -> California

The law used as example is: CCPA

The CCPA states that if someone fails to respect a user's privacy rights, the website owner may be charged $7,500 per visitor or violation. Now, let's say a company has 10 million users from California. The website either fails to delete IP logs of the visitors or suffers a data breach. The company only makes $100,000 per month through ads, with operations costs of $10,000 per month.

Can the company be given a $7,500 * 10 million = $75 billion dollar fine? Are there any laws that prevent this?

In general, can any law just demand any amount from anyone?

edited tags; edited tags
Link
Trish
  • 45.2k
  • 2
  • 93
  • 182
Loading
Grammar and punctuation
Source Link
Ryan M
  • 10.3k
  • 2
  • 47
  • 63
Loading
Grammar and punctuation
Source Link
Loading
edited title
Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading