Law Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for legal professionals, students, and others with experience or interest in law. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
I would like to create a similar icon to one used in another software (e.g. the "Share" icon on iOS, or the "Crop" tool in Photoshop).
My icons are not going to be pixel-wise identical to the reference icons, but they may appear very similar to users.
Is it legal to do so?
Please note that there is no intention to copy the general look of another software, and there is even no intention make the entire icon set in my software similar to a reference software.
If the similarity could create confusion as to whether the original product has endorsed the new product, there may be trademark infringement.
If the similarity suggests that the new product is "derivative" of the older product, this may suggest copyright infringement.
Without knowing the setting, the level of originality and the general complexity of the icons it is not possible to know. But generally, those are the two areas of law that the creation of new icons would be rubbing up against.
