If a person inherits the hunting rights that are deeded and recorded, can the land owner force one to give the hunting rights back to him just because he wants to sell the land?
If I inherited the hunting rights that was purchased by my father, deeded and >recorded, can the land owner make me give the hunting rights back to him just >because he wants to sell the land?
There is a legal term for the hunting rights your father purchased: "personal easement in gross".
Unfortunately, it appears that you probably did not actually inherit the rights because personal easements in gross (unlike commercial ones) are not inheritable or transferrable:
Because noncommercial easements in gross are treated as a right of personal enjoyment for the original holder, they are generally not transferable. Recreational rights such as hunting, camping and fishing are the most common examples of nontransferable, noncommercial-easements in gross.
Usually, a personal easement in gross terminates on the death of the easement owner.
Therefore, unless Alabama has a law that explicitly makes personal easements in gross inheritable/transferrable (which, upon quick search, does not appear to be the case, but you really should talk to a lawyer to find out for sure), you actually do not have any hunting rights on the land.
Because the owner of the land thinks that you still have the rights, you have two options:
- Try to convince him (e.g. tell him to talk to a lawyer) that you do not have the hunting rights, so there is nothing for him to worry about; OR
- If he still wants you to explicitly relinquish any hunting rights in the unlikely case you have them, you can do so for a consideration (e.g. $1 or whatever you agree on). This would be a contract between you and him that will give him (and his prospective buyers) a peace of mind.