My roomate hasn't arrived yet and I haven't met him yet but a big package of water in plastic bottles has been delivered to the room for him. My metal reusable water bottle is moldy and I didn't get a chance to buy soap to wash it so I took one of my roomate's waters for myself with the intention that I would reuse it a few times and by then I would've gotten a chance to wash my metal water bottle. I feel like I might be stealing and don't want to get in trouble for it but I'm sure my roomate would consent after I meet him. Should I not do this? I saw this searching on Google and it seems like a big deal: https://www.avvo.com/legal-answers/caught-stealing-under--10-of-merchandise-from-walm-1013930.html

  • 3
    Do you really need legal analysis as to whether you should steal something? – bdb484 Jul 7 '18 at 3:12
  • but whats legally right isnt always whats morally right though am i right? Like if you're caught speeding trying to save someone that would be morally right but legally wrong? Or will the judges take into account that you were trying to save someone? – Larry lawrence Jul 10 '18 at 15:31
  • If your question is about what's morally right, you should ask your priest. If your question is whether letting your dishes get moldy is a defense to a theft charge, you can probably guess the answer. – bdb484 Jul 10 '18 at 16:23
  • But I'm not religious though. Isn't the point of law to enforce what's morally right? That seems obvious to me. The point of law is so that everything is fair and good which is the definition of morals. Or is the law inflexible and unfair? – Larry lawrence Jul 12 '18 at 17:45

From a legal POV you are stealing, and are in the wrong. The correct thing would be to get his consent (phone call?) prior to taking it.

If you have already taken it, you should replace it ASAP. That does not mean you did not steal it, but it reduces the impact of your actions.

From a practical POV you are setting yourself up for issues with your roommate, and possibly get a bad reputation, but it's unlikely the law would get involved over something as trivial as a bottle of water.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.