Law Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for legal professionals, students, and others with experience or interest in law. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this community
Landlords are not allowed to discrimate against a sex when renting to tenants as this is one of the protected classes.
How do universities get away with discriminating against a sex when filling dorms though? Public universities declare a specific dorm 'all male' or 'all female'.
From what I can determine, there has not been a legal challenge to the practice that reached a high enough level to get on my radar, so it's not clearly prohibited or allowed. Turning to the relevant federal regulations, the implementation of the Fair Housing Act, the law hinges in part on an
Aggrieved person includes any person who—
(a) Claims to have been injured by a discriminatory housing practice; or
(b) Believes that such person will be injured by a discriminatory housing practice that is about to occur.
In order to sue a university because they offer sex-separated halls, floors or rooms, a plaintiff would have to show that they have been harmed by being given such a choice. Reading the prohibitions in §100.50, there is no obvious "Discriminat[ion] in the terms, conditions or privileges of sale or rental of a dwelling, or in the provision of services or facilities", and it does not "otherwise makes unavailable or denies dwellings". Cases like McLaurin v. Oklahoma State Regents, 339 U.S. 637 (a case putting an end to the "separate but equal" doctrine) include reference to the fact that appellant was harmed ("The restrictions imposed upon appellant impair and inhibit his ability to study, to engage in discussions and exchange views with other students, and, in general, to learn his profession"). Analogously, the relatively rare black-only residences of UC Davis and Cal State LA might be targeted in a discrimination suit, if plaintiffs can make the required legal argument that there is harm.
In Australia there is a specific exemption in the Sex Discrimination Act - s34(2):
Nothing in Division 1 or 2 applies to or in relation to the provision of accommodation, where the accommodation is provided solely for persons of one sex who are students at an educational institution.
Such exemptions are pretty universal in anti-discrimination laws.
Part of this is that students are not a protected class under the Fair Housing Act (FHA). So an educational organization that offers housing, can say that the housing is for students only, and not offer housing to the general public. That doesn't mean the FHA doesn't apply, but what it does mean is that students can be discriminated against.
So, first a college can say that they only admit male or female students (an all-one-sex college, not many exist but they are out there). They can also state that the housing that they offer is for students only, which would limit a dormitory to all male/female occupants.
Second, a college that is mixed-gender can provide both types of housing and say that one type of housing is for males and the other females. They can limit this by only admitting X number of male students and Y number of female students (my college did this and had limited female housing, with about a 10:1 male-female admittance).
This isn't discrimination as it applies under the FHA. They aren't offering rooms to the general public (you need to be a student to get into the dorms). That means that these rooms are being assigned based on sex, but you are not denied a room based on gender (you may be denied admission, but that is another topic). For example you usually don't walk through the dorms and pick out your favorite room like you would an apartment, they are assigned.
FHA applies to students, a female student can be assigned a female dorm, and a male in a male dorm, but it is not discrimination to say that "Dorm X is all female, Dorm Y is all male". So long as the policy applies to all students equally, it is not discrimination.
So, for example an all-female school can only admit females. It can say that "only students allowed in the dorms", and because only females are students, that means that only females can live there.
Off campus housing is an entirely different matter if it is not owned or operated by the school.
