4

Scenario

I asked a fellow dog-walker to prevent their dog from snapping at mine. They became very irate but I just walked away from the situation. I may have said "Please keep your dog under control in future" as a parting shot.

I presumed this was the end of it but months later this person spotted me, called the police and told them I had committed hate speech.

I was told by the police that they wouldn't arrest me straight away but I must come to the police station for interview the following day.

In fact the police called me the next day and said the complaint had been withdrawn and there was no evidence of wrong doing. They even apologised.

Question

This whole thing was completely unexpected but if I'd had the presence of mind to record the encounter on my mobile phone it would have proved I hadn't behaved badly.

Am I allowed to video such encounters under English Law?

Would such a video be admissible as evidence?

  • 1
    A lot will depend on where this took place: a park owned by the council, somebody's front garden, or a public street? – Tim Lymington Nov 21 '18 at 17:51
-1

You are within your rights to video record the encounter (providing you aren't breaking the law by doing so) and such a record would be admissible evidence in court.

  • However, it might be hard to prove that the encounter recorded was the one the other party referred to. Hate speech could have been used on some other occasion, in theory. – David Siegel Feb 20 at 0:23
  • 1
    It seems to me that the phrase "providing you aren't breaking the law by doing so" doesn't really belong in an answer to the question "Am I allowed to video such encounters under English Law?" – phoog Jun 20 at 4:20

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.