1

Certain US federal employees are required to work without pay in the event of a government shutdown (i.e. budgetary incompetence). If you are classified as an an essential employee, you must work with no idea of when you will get paid.

How can this be legal? Why is it not a criminal offense as a sort of temporary enslavement?

  • Freedom of contract. The employees agreed to those terms, didn't they? – Greendrake Jan 18 at 19:51
  • @Greendrake Freedom of Contract does not allow illegal activity, does it? Slavery, even temporary slavery, is illegal. – RichF Jan 18 at 20:06
  • What on Earth does pay or lack of pay have to do with slavery? They're completely unrelated concepts. Slaves can be paid, non-slaves can work for free. – cpast Jan 18 at 20:18
5

Employees are only required to work in the sense that refusal to report can result in discipline (like reprimand or firing) and forfeit of whatever money you would have earned had you shown up. This is exactly the same way federal employees (or most employees, for that matter) are always required to work. The fact that they're not being paid on time has nothing to do with whether it's slavery. That's because pay has nothing to do with slavery. Slavery is forced labor and/or ownership of people, and civilian federal employees are just as free to quit as they normally are. Military personnel can't freely quit, but they can never freely quit. Nothing relevant has changed for either group.

Not paying employees is potentially a violation of labor law, and the government in fact lost a lawsuit after the last shutdown for violating the FLSA. If that happens this time too, they'll have to pay damages.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.