I know that a contract does not need to be signed. In general what counts as accepting a contract? I know some people can be tricky with words. For example if you emailed someone a contract (for example agreement to do freelance writing) and they reply "this seems sufficient" does that count? Or are the words "this seems sufficient" too ambiguous to accept a contract?


What counts as an offer being accepted?

Any conduct that reflects a reasonable conclusion that the offeree knowingly and willfully approved of the terms and conditions of the offer.

Acceptance can be manifested verbally or in writing (as the other answer rightly pointed out); alternatively, it can be inferred from the offeree's subsequent conduct that indicates (1) his enjoyment of benefits that are attributable to the contract, and/or (2) his efforts to comply with his duties as per that contract.

The language "this seems sufficient" constitutes an expression of knowing and willful acceptance, and it will ordinarily be construed that way unless the offeree is able to prove/persuade that the expression referred to something other than actually entering the contract.

This and many other aspects of contract law are similar among many jurisdictions: all of the US, Canada, many European countries, and elsewhere. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts thoroughly formulates the doctrine of contract law, and it is frequently used as reference in opinions released by U.S. courts.

  • To me, "This seems sufficient" would indicate that the contract is fine, that there is nothing missing or unclear in the view of the person receiving it, but I wouldn't see it as acceptance. Especially since one could have written "this seems sufficient, so I accept this contract" which would have been 100 percent clear. – gnasher729 Jan 26 at 13:56
  • @gnasher729 You might be right, but a statement of sufficiency denotes approval or being satisfied by the terms of the offer, whence acceptance may be inferred. Hence the importance that the offeree qualify the expression "this seems sufficient" if he does not intend to enter a contract [yet], or be able to persuade that the offeror impermissibly stretched the scope or meaning of that expression. See also Black's Law Dictionary defin. of "Sufficient Consideration" (in entry for Consideration): "One deemed by the law of sufficient value to support an ordinary contract between parties". – Iñaki Viggers Jan 26 at 14:49
  • If someone says "this seems sufficient", rather than "this is sufficient", then they are qualifying their statement by saying that there are no obvious problems with the contract. It leaves the possibility that they will find something in the fine print that they object to. – Acccumulation Jan 26 at 20:38
  • @Acccumulation Maybe, but see the Restatement at § 209(3) as to "a writing which in view of its completeness and specificity reasonably appears to be a complete agreement" (cf. a standard in the vein of strictly denotes). Depending on the nature of possible non-obvious problems, other doctrines might apply (example: contra proferentem) without negating the formation of the contract. – Iñaki Viggers Jan 26 at 21:19
  • 1
    I think acceptance would be inferred given the conduct of the parties i.e. the implicit agreement – clipclopshop Jan 27 at 10:48

For a contract to be valid there needs to be an offer and an acceptance. This can be verbal or in writing. In this case, emailing a contract would be an obvious offer and the reply "this seems sufficient" to me would be understood as an acceptance. The reason that I would consider this to be an acceptance is because it is generally understood that once a contract is proposed the opposite party will either accept the deal, reject it and propose a new contract, or reject it entirely. Also it's worth noting that different states have slightly different laws on contracts.

I'm not a lawyer, this is just my take from some light reading on contract law.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.