-3

Left or right hand dominance is congenital. Suppose a child incurred a disorder such as dyslexia from being taught to use the non-dominant hand (as many have been due to the lack of left handed equipment, or teacher preference for conformity). Who would be responsible for the malpractice?

The comments in this article suggest many children were negatively affected from this. Do any of them have a legal case?

(Notice there are a few left handed desks on the far left in this picture. Ideally I think they should not isolate the left-handed people on the edge of the classroom.)

0

Can children that are force to write with the wrong hand that has developed a major disorder bring suit for malpractice?

That would be an unfounded and futile claim. The plaintiff would have a very hard time proving that his alleged disorder originated from being forced to write with the wrong hand.

Even if an expert witness lent himself to support plaintiff's claim, it will always be easier for the defendant to outweigh that testimony by presenting abundant evidence that is more credible. And that is a big if because plaintiff's expert witness has so much to lose in terms of credentials & qualifications by endorsing such a bizarre diagnosis.

|improve this answer|||||
  • Its not so bizzare. anythinglefthanded.co.uk/being-lh/children/… Obviously that page is not in itself proof, but it does suggest that the claim should not be dismissed. – Paul Johnson Jul 6 '19 at 11:37
  • 2
    @PaulJohnson I am by no means knowledgeable in neurology, but a website with generic statements and a link about a film which "does not seem to make much of the forced change in handedness" is a too sloppy approach on the author's part. It is unfortunate that some people are forced to change handedness (I am left-handed and luckily grew up in a great environment), yet associating suppressed handedness with mental disorders seems quite mistaken and thus it misses the true causes of those people's difficulties. – Iñaki Viggers Jul 6 '19 at 11:59
  • You may well be right. I just don't want to dismiss the claim without proper investigation. – Paul Johnson Jul 6 '19 at 12:07
  • 2
    @Muze "I want to think" is exactly the wrong attitude here (and in pretty much everything). As soon as you start feeling that you want a particular answer, start searching for evidence to the contrary. Only when you don't find it after a diligent search can you start having any confidence that the world really is as you want it to be. Also, try asking over on Skeptics.SE. They specialize in this kind of question. – Paul Johnson Jul 7 '19 at 7:44

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.