0

On musescore.com, there are several song arrangements released under CC-BY-NC (or CC-BY-NC-SA or CC-BY-NC-ND) licenses. However, musescore.com won't let you download many of these unless you have a Pro account with them (which costs money). This seems to me like a clear and blatant violation of the "NC" terms of those licenses. Is this actually the case, or is it legal somehow?

  • Did the service receive the works under that NC license, or do they hold the necessary rights to offer the work under that license (without being bound by it themselves). That also happens to be the core issue of the question whether Stack Exchange had the right to retroactively change the user content license: they can only do that if they aren't bound by the CC-BY-SA license themselves. – amon Dec 29 '19 at 9:01
  • @amon: Question related to the issue you mention in the last sentence: When I have the right to use/copy/publish/distribute/etc. content, does this also imply the right to license the content? – unor Dec 30 '19 at 13:03
1

If you read their user agreement, you will see that the content which is available to those who have a subscription may be owned by the company, or may be owned by users who upload such content. They allow content owners to specify license terms. §7 of the agreement is where the uploader licenses material to the company:

you hereby grant to Musescore a limited license to use, modify, delete from, add to, publicly perform, publicly display, reproduce, and distribute such User Generated Content solely on, through or in connection with the Service, including, without limitation, through the Service to applications, widgets, websites or mobile, desktop, including, without limitation, distributing part or all of the Service and any User Generated Content included therein, in any media formats and through any media channels, including without limitation, third party social media and streaming platforms, and shall constitute a waiver of any rights, ''moral rights,'' or any similar rights under any jurisdiction. Except as expressly provided for herein, this limited license does not grant Musescore the right to sell or otherwise distribute your User Generated Content outside of the Service.

Nothing in the license that uploaders grant to the company prohibits using the work in a commercial setting. Nothing prohibits a user from setting the license for their work as plain CC-BY or even CC0.

|improve this answer|||||

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.