Trevino v. Thaler, Oral arguments

MR. OLDHAM: Well, Your Honor, I think you could do one of two things. You could always certify the question with the Court of Criminal Appeals if you thought that the question -- that the answer turns on what the Texas procedures are and that the parties disagree with them.

JUSTICE BREYER: I tried that once in a case involving Pennsylvania, and the result was such that I resolved never to do it again.


JUSTICE BREYER: But -- but don't say never. All right. So one thing we got --

JUSTICE ALITO: That was a case in which -- that was the case in which the Court unwisely reversed a certain Third Circuit decision.

What case were Justices Breyer and Alito referring to?


A blog post tracked this to Fiore v. White, a 1999 case in which Breyer wrote an opinion certifying a question to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, after which SCOTUS reversed the Third Circuit per curiam. The Third Circuit opinion in question was written by Circuit Judge Samuel Alito.

  • 1
    So, I went and read the opinions, and one thing I'm still missing is why Justice Breyer decided, in retrospect, it was such a bad idea; it looks like it went rather smoothly. I can think of why I think it was a bad idea (letting a state decide whether its own procedure was constitutional), but why did Justice Breyer? – Owen Nov 5 '15 at 5:29

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.