Suppose I see an innovative piece of (commercial) software that delivers considerable, non-trivial functionality.

Can I re-implement it? Suppose I study it carefully, work out what it does and how it does it, and then write my own software to do the same thing. I haven't (knowingly) copied any specific part of that system, but I have replicated the system as a whole ...its design. So have I infringed the copyright of the original system?

Consider the possibility of translating a Harry Potter novel into French. If I change the names, I could produce a text that didn't contain a single word of Rowling's original. But I believe that doing so would infring Rowling's copyright. What is the situation with software?

  • 2
    Does this answer your question? How to recreate functionality without violating software code copyright laws? Apr 7, 2020 at 18:51
  • 1
    Your analogy is not quite right; a better analogy would be that you read Harry Potter, and then want to make your own novel (in French, say) about a boy who goes to a magical wizard school. You could certainly make your own version of such a story without infringing on copyrights. J K Rowling doesn't 'own' the idea of a magical school or magical spells.
    – Brandin
    Apr 8, 2020 at 7:52

1 Answer 1


You can't compare a novel and a computer program that way. With a novel, the expression and the essence of the work are the same. With a computer program, while the expression is hard work to create, and often is very original, the essence of the work is what it does.

So I can create a totally independent computer program doing the exact same thing, without any copying whatsoever. With your novel, the essence of the work is copied. Unless you change Harry Potter to a pot smoking sanitary engineer, change his wand to a guitar, move him to a different world, where is not surrounded by fellow wizards but by intelligent, speaking animals, and write the whole thing a few years before Mrs. Rowling did.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.