1

The living room in my house is monitored by CCTV with audio. Will that be admissible in court?

  • 3
    What part of "you cannot record the call without permission" do you think would be avoidable by doing this? – Nij Apr 14 at 8:38
  • I would not be recording the call. I would be recording my house, myself and my living room – Ulkoma Apr 14 at 8:40
  • 5
    ... while deliberately playing the call through speaker, into equipment you know is recording it, without telling or receiving permission from the other person. You end up with a recording of the call - in what world is this entire situation not exactly recording the call? – Nij Apr 14 at 8:46
  • 1
    If "your honour" hates one thing, then it is a smart ass. Judges are supposed to be objective and unbiased, but if you work hard enough on it, you can stop them from being objective. – gnasher729 Apr 14 at 21:31
  • 2
    As a general rule, courts tend not to tolerate transparent attempts at word game loopholes, or other general dickery and violations of common sense. If your rationale can be phrased with "technically..." then you are, technically, gonna get reamed by the judge for trying to pull that off. Some exceptions may apply to corporations; they seem to not always be held to the same "reasonable person" standard that people are, being as they're not people, and they don't really do anything at all without a contract that makes the loopholes into features rather than exploits. – zibadawa timmy Apr 15 at 10:31
6

The law 'doesn't care' how the call is recorded. What matters is whether or not you should inform / should have informed the participant(s) in the circumstances.

In circumstances where you are acting as an ordinary member of the public, in the course of a purely personal or household activity, not in a journalistic capacity, regulated business or other circumstances where the rules may differ:

In the UK it is not unlawful for a private person to record a phone call without the permission or foreknowledge of the other participant(s) - provided the recording is for 'personal use'.

If you intend to share the content of the call with a third-party or make it public, then you must inform the person ahead of recording it.

If you try to use a covertly recorded call as evidence in court, the court may or may not exclude it depending on the circumstances.

| improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.