Consider an LLC that owns a rental home worth $700,000 and has bank debt of $500,000. A renter slips, falls, sues, and wins a $300,000 settlement. Is the bank debt senior to the lawsuit, leaving the lawsuit $100,000 short? LLC members are wiped out, but with the limited liability of an LLC the story ends there?

What if the $500,000 loan is owed to one of the LLC members? Does that change anything, assuming the member has a fully documented and separate loan agreement with the LLC?

  • "secured debt"? Aug 15, 2020 at 23:39
  • I think so, secured and perfected, as the asset is a home with no other form of debt or security on it. So yes, a member loan to the LLC secured by a home. The main point here is to protect the value of this home from other claims that may arise later, e.g. any future renter legal action. So is it safe to say any member loan amount secured by the home would be prioritized ahead of other claims? That the secured loan is held by a member of the LLC would not pierce the corporate veil by the fact that the single LLC member and the loan holder are the same person?
    – Kim Miller
    Aug 17, 2020 at 23:53

1 Answer 1


Is the debt secured?

Lenders can lend money secured or unsecured. If they lend it secured then what is the security? That is, what property secured the loan?

For your example that could be a mortgage over the land or a charge over the assets of the LLC or both. In this particular example, it doesn’t make a difference but if the sale of the property only realised $400,000 and the security was a mortgage only then only $400,000 is secured and the rest is unsecured.

Further, in some jurisdictions it is a requirement that security interests be “perfected” by complying with administrative provisions to register the security interest on some sort of public record. If this doesn’t happen, the debt is unsecured.

Secured creditors rank ahead of unsecured creditors and in the order spelled out in the contracts or equally if the contracts are silent. Unsecured creditors rank in the order spelled out in 11 USC 507.

The members of the LLC are not necessarily protected from the bankruptcy if it is possible to pierce the corporate veil.

  • I'm hearing you say that a "secured" mortgage in place today ranks ahead of any subsequently arising liability claim against the LLC. The state of jurisdiction is Georgia where I'm reading " GA Code § 11-9-310 (2015) -- (a) General rule; perfection by filing. ... A financing statement must be filed to perfect all security interests. law.justia.com/codes/georgia/2015/title-11/article-9/part-3/… Can the corporate veil be pierced if a Member is the lender, or should a members secured interest hold?
    – Kim Miller
    Aug 16, 2020 at 21:02

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .