0

This is bit of a follow up to How can a community based not-for-profit be sued?

A dispute arose with a local kink community getting sued.

The open letter was addressed to ... Lyncaster’s ...and alleged that he had invited a minor to his home, ...for a discussion related to ... (BDSM),...

Obviously sex acts with a minor are illegal. However, some people have different interpretations of what is sexual. My question is, in the eyes of the law, what is defined as a sex act?

For example, if someone finds it sexual to be tied up, if an adult did this to a minor would that be considered rape? In law does sex mean involving genitalia? Is talking about sexual things with a minor illegal (if it's not intended for educational purposes e.g. Sex Ed)?

  • 2
    Worth observing that there is no such thing as a definition of a "sex act" "in the eyes of the law" in general, in a common law jurisdiction. Words and phrases have legal meanings only in particular "as applied" contexts. A phrase like "sex act" can and does mean different things in different contexts. What constitutes a "sex act" for a rape law and what constitutes a "sex act" for a pornography law, and what constitutes a sex act for a cow insemination contract or an artificial insemination arrangement for a couple that wants kids, are not necessarily the same. The answers illustrate that. – ohwilleke Aug 24 '20 at 23:11
1

It is kind of irrelevant to that case, since the question is whether the statements lowered the defendant in the eyes of the public (or some subset). So the suit does not hinge on what a "sex act" is for criminal purposes. W.r.t. criminal law, "sex act" is also irrelevant. The relevant laws are Part V of the Canadian Criminal Code. The offenses that are defined under the law all require touching (151-153), though can involve inviting or counseling to touch without actual touching. So it depends on what was said in the discussion, as far as an allegation of committing a crime is concerned.

  • To my understanding something is not defamation if it's true. So if Lyncaster did discuss BDSM with a minor, wouldn't that mean his case against the society for calling him out would be thrown out? Or is this somehow not a matter of defamation? – Lobsteroid1 Aug 31 '20 at 22:33
-1

I can’t find the relevant law in but it will be similar to most other common law jurisdictions so let’s look at .

Section 61HC of the Crimes Act 1900 says:

61HC   Meaning of “sexual act”

(1)  For the purposes of this Division, sexual act means an act (other than sexual touching) carried out in circumstances where a reasonable person would consider the act to be sexual.

(2)  The matters to be taken into account in deciding whether a reasonable person would consider an act to be sexual include—

(a)  whether the area of the body involved in the act is a person’s genital area or anal area or (in the case of a female person, or transgender or intersex person identifying as female) the person’s breasts, whether or not the breasts are sexually developed, or

(b)  whether the person carrying out the act does so for the purpose of obtaining sexual arousal or sexual gratification, or

(c)  whether any other aspect of the act (including the circumstances in which it is carried out) makes it sexual.

(3)  An act carried out for genuine medical or hygienic purposes is not a sexual act.

A reasonable person in the context of a “kink community” would consider BDSM to be sexual under (2)(b) & (c) irrespective if there was involvement of genitalia, anal regions or breasts. However, discussion of BDSM in the context of a health class within a high school curriculum is not a sexual act because a reasonable person would not consider it one

Note that a “sexual act” is different from “sexual touching” or “sexual intercourse” and the particular circumstances determine whether any of them is a crime in any given situation. A sexual act involving children (under 16) is a crime.

  • 1
    Criminal law is in the exclusive domain of the Parliament of Canada, so there won't be any BC law defining criminal sexual acts. – Ross Ridge Aug 23 '20 at 23:38
  • 1
    @RossRidge ah -I did not know that. – Dale M Aug 23 '20 at 23:39

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.