0

Is it similar to the distinction in the USA between a FOIA request and one made under the Privacy Act?

Corollary: what is the origin of the Subject Access Request system, and why does the name seem to be shared by other European countries?

Corollary 2: did the legal phrase Freedom Of Information first come to be used in the US or the UK, or even elsewhere?

1

There are two main differences between a SAR and a FOI request. A subject access request is about your personal data held by any organization, whereas a freedom of information request is a more general one about information held by government organizations.

Example SAR: I'd like to see my credit file.

Example FOI: I'd like to see the report saying that 'project X' was expected to go $2 million over budget and 90% likely to fail.

The subject access request comes from European law: currently the General Data Protection Regulation but was also found in predecessors.

The modern Freedom of Information principles come largely from the USA, as a reaction to the idea that government had become less accountable during the cold war era. As such I think most people would regard the US act as a landmark, although it's not exactly the first.

2
  • What types of information can be omitted from responses to a subject access request, and can the perceived intentions of the filer in submitting it be taken into account when deciding whether to grant or refuse it?
    – Jackie FJA
    Oct 12 '20 at 12:21
  • FOIA can be denied based on "this is confidential for state security reasons"
    – Trish
    Oct 12 '20 at 13:14

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.