In this online multiple choice question, I picked the last choice. I agree that the first choice is true, but why's the last one wrong?

enter image description here

  • The posted answer has it, I think. It’s a question about statutory interpretation requiring multiple choice answer interpretation! Like, imagine a friend gives you their credit card and asks you to pick them up something from the store. There’s no reason for you to think that because you are allowed to go buy item X, you’re also allowed to go buy items Y and Z. Finally, a good rule of thumb for questions like this, where you just don’t know if it could be between two... an answer that contains always, never, every, etc is almost certainly the wrong one. Never be so certain!
    – A.fm.
    Feb 15 at 21:12

Break it down then take it to an absurd extreme to prove a point:

HMRC exercises its powers to collect PAYE tax

For the purposes to fund the NHS and to pay for all its employees to have a free hair cut once the current lockdown has been lifted

One of which is allowed by statute (PAYE not hair cuts)

  • The free hair cuts might be a public health measure to combat Cholera, Typhoid fever and other 1900 "contagious diseases"
    – Trish
    Feb 15 at 13:44
  • I'm thinking more about the here-and-now. I last had my haircut in 2019 BC (that's Before Covid) and I'm starting to look like it's the 70's all over again - if you weren't around then it was an eclectic mix of Farrah Flicks, mullets and mohecans.
    – Rock Ape
    Mar 31 at 0:20

This site is temporarily in read only mode and not accepting new answers.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .