1

I want to know if dog meat is illegal in USA.

Is its sale banned?

Is there any criminal law against it?

Is a fine of any kind imposed?

Note: I don't in any way support dog meat. I just want to know the law and culture.

5

There appear to be no explicit federal laws against the practice. Each state has its own laws and many would depend on the individual interpretation of the genera "Humane Treatment of Animals" statutes.

It appears that individual states do have laws against killing cats and dogs for food.

The California law also protects "any animal traditionally or commonly kept as a pet or companion,"

Is it legal to eat your cat?

Few states have specific laws barring the use of pets for food. The ones that do typically ban the slaughter or sale of dog and cat meat. The state of New York expressly prohibits "any person to slaughter or butcher domesticated dog (canis familiaris) or domesticated cat (felis catus or domesticus) to create food, meat or meat products for human or animal consumption." It's not clear whether the eating itself is outlawed or only the butchery. If you managed to buy dog or cat flesh from someone else who broke the anti-slaughter law, you might be OK. The law also doesn't cover ferrets, gerbils, parakeets, or other less familiar pet species. (Although the general anti-cruelty law might protect exotics.)

California's anti-pet-eating law has a broader reach. It bars possession of the carcass, so having bought your cat steaks from someone else wouldn't be a useful alibi. The California law also protects "any animal traditionally or commonly kept as a pet or companion," rather than just Fido and Fluffy. The statute is somewhat untested, though, so no one really knows which animals are included. Pigs are not, even though they are commonly kept as pets, because they are farm animals. Horses are specifically covered by a different section of the code. There's no precedent on iguanas, goldfish, or boa constrictors.

In most of the country, the legality of pet-eating would come down to the specific language of the general animal cruelty statute and how a judge interpreted it. Some states, such as Virginia, bar the unnecessary killing of an animal, with a specific exemption for "farming activities." In those places, it's very likely that killing a cat for dinner would get you in trouble, because the killing wouldn't be necessary, and cats aren't commonly associated with farming.

On the other end of the spectrum are states like Missouri, where very few restrictions are placed on when, why, and how an owner can kill his pet. In these areas, it would be difficult to lock up a cat-eater, unless his chosen means of slaughter were particularly inhumane.


There was also a report that a Los Angeles restaurant had been granted permission to consume and sell dog meat (American Restaurant Granted Permission To Sell Dog Meat - link now dead).

However, according to fact checking site Snopes.com, this is not true: Fact Check - American Restaurant Granted Permission to Sell Dog Meat:

Claim: A restaurant in Los Angeles or New York has been granted legal permission to serve dog meat.

FALSE

  • The story about the LA restaurant is likely fake - I edited to indicate this. – sleske Aug 23 '18 at 10:00
  • FWIW, Colorado has no law prohibiting human consumption of dogs or killing dogs for that purpose. One of our current candidates for Governor has enacting such a law as a component of his campaign's agenda. – ohwilleke Aug 23 '18 at 16:55
3

The House of Representatives in September 2018 passed this bill to ban slaughter or commerce in dog or cat parts for human consumption.

  • I can imagine each culture's bias shaping the law as to what animals may and may not be slaughtered for food. Those that would presume to tell others what NOT to eat should be prepared to denied their favorite meat, whether it is steak or any other conceivable item. No presumption should be made as to what meat I would \ would not find acceptable – gatorback Sep 23 '18 at 19:10
  • 1
    The bill you mention has not yet passed. It was introduced in the House and has been referred to a subcommittee; but it's unknown whether or not it will "re-emerge" from the committee to be voted on. Bills quite frequently "die in committee", for better or for worse. – Michael Seifert Sep 23 '18 at 20:36

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.