0

This question is rather US-based but perspectives from all other countries (UK, Aus, CAN, etc.) are much appreciated.

The situation is as follows. An expat gives some money away to a friend in his home country, which she uses to do the business. He doesn't have the custody, ownership, or any other legal association with such money. For example, his friend may buy shares or register a company without him as an owner. A decade pasts and her business goes well. At the same time, assume our expat fella doesn't have a good run and he's now unemployed. Luckily, his friend becomes an oligarch, so she sends him a large sum.

The question is: What is the expat's taxable duty on the money he receives in the country he's living, say the US? In particular, is tax only applicable on the money he gets? Or, is he also somehow responsible for the, say, capital gains, of the friend's business? Does the answer change based on whether or not: (1) It's a personal loan instead of a giveaway? (2) He's aware of the friend's business or consults her, such as which stock to buy or operational strategies of the company, even though he still doesn't have legal associations with her business as mentioned above?

EDIT to add further clarification based on comments: I'm interested in knowing in particular if the expat is subject to any tax considerations from what his friend does with the money? For example, the friend makes 1k in capital gain in the first year from investing activities, does that impose any tax on the expat? Again, the money is legally no longer his money even though he may be aware of what the friend does (like, they talk about what to buy or sell or he may even give her advice).

5
  • 2
    Are you asking about a case where a friend (A) gives a friend (B) monetary gift out of generosity no strings attached and later B gives a monetary gift to A out of gratitude but with no compulsion? Commented Nov 24, 2022 at 6:50
  • 3
    In that case the expat had to check what taxes are due in the USA if you give gifts, and in the home country when you receive gifts, at the time of the first donation. And now they have to check the laws in the opposite direction.
    – gnasher729
    Commented Nov 24, 2022 at 7:42
  • @GeorgeWhite There's no string attached from the legal standpoint. Even though expat A may expect a gratitude in return, there isn't any formal document binding with his money once he gives it away.
    – NonSleeper
    Commented Nov 24, 2022 at 13:28
  • @gnasher729 Thanks. I think the points you mention are understandable. I'm however also interested in knowing what happens between the two transactions. In particular, is the expat subject to any tax considerations from what his friend does with the money? For example, the friend makes 1k in capital gain in the first year from investing activities, does that impose any tax on the expat? Again the money is legally no longer his money even though he may be aware of what the friend does (like, they talk about what to buy or sell or he may even give her advice).
    – NonSleeper
    Commented Nov 24, 2022 at 13:36
  • 2
    If it is truly a gift it doesn’t matter. If it is an investment that is being portrayed as a gift to avoid taxes that is another matter. Commented Nov 24, 2022 at 15:33

1 Answer 1

1

No tax is payable

A gift in the hands of the receiver is non-taxable and is non-deductible to the giver, gifts to registered Deductible Gift Recipients (aka charities) excepted.

To be a gift it must be truly obligation free on both parties - if there is any sort of business type relationship between them then the onus is on the taxpayer to prove it was a gift.

Both of the transactions you describe appear to be gifts.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .