4

It's common to see companies say that "all proceeds" from selling something, or from admission, will go to charity. What's not clear to me is whether that's

  • all the revenue, or all of the pre-tax price and they're just saying proceeds to be clear they're not donating the sales tax
  • all the profit, after allowing for -- well, what? cost of materials? cost of materials plus time of the staff who sell it to you and rent for the building they do it in? All that plus corporate overhead and franchise fees?
  • pretty much any number between zero and the price, whatever the company feels like

Is there a legal meaning? If Tim Hortons sells a million smile cookies for a dollar each are they obliged to donate a million dollars? I note their 7-year old web page has a * on it that doesn't lead anywhere, and I can't find the fine print:

WHEN YOU PURCHASE A SMILE COOKIE AT PARTICIPATING TIM HORTONS LOCATIONS, your full $1* goes to help support local charities like hospitals, food banks and children’s programs.

And if it happens that Tim's donates the whole price-before-taxes, is that because that's the meaning of proceeds, or just what they are choosing to do? Do false advertising laws impose a meaning for this phrasing?

3
  • Presumably the non-participating Tom Horton locations are funding the overheads, since the quote says "your full $1". Commented Nov 11, 2023 at 20:42
  • 1
    but with a star. And no footnote to go with the star. That's the question. (And there's no need for non participating locations to fund the overheads; everything they sell that's not a smile cookie can fund the overheads.) Commented Nov 11, 2023 at 21:06
  • Presumably the * refers to the small print two lines below, which makes it clear that only $1 of the purchase price (and not the tax paid by the customer) is donated. So if the customer pays say $1.25 including taxes, only $1, the actual cost, is donated. Commented Nov 11, 2023 at 22:39

1 Answer 1

1

It has two meanings

There are gross proceeds which is all the income that the sale of the item realised, and there are net proceeds which is the gross proceeds less the direct costs of selling that particular item. Direct costs would typically include the cost of the item, sales or value added taxes, shipping costs etc. but not corporate overheads.

Assuming that Canada has laws against deceptive and misleading conduct, it is almost certainly the first of these that is meant. However, it would be better if they used a different word.

0

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .