Questions tagged [fifth-amendment]

Rights enumerated in or derived from the fifth amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

Filter by
Sorted by
Tagged with
3 votes
1 answer
886 views

Is a judge or jury "to assume or presume" testimony not given after invoking the fifth amendment would have been negative in a civil trial?

In CNN's ‘Very bad strategy’: Legal expert reacts to Trump’s latest attack on judge after 03:11 there's the following exchange with former federal prosecutor Renato Mariotti: CNN: And of course, when ...
uhoh's user avatar
  • 768
-3 votes
3 answers
536 views

Does double jeopardy apply if you commit the same crime twice?

Suppose someone were to rob a convenience store, be charged with robbery, then be found not guilty in court. After they are found innocent, that same person robs the same convenience store again. ...
Stevoisiak's user avatar
2 votes
1 answer
471 views

Has New Jersey v. Andrews ever been successfully challenged?

New Jersey v. Andrews is relatively new case law. Has it ever been successfully challenged at the district court level? I'm aware of several cases where the state has seized a citizen's smartphone ...
user75575's user avatar
  • 127
20 votes
3 answers
7k views

Can a defendant remain silent (invoke 5th amendment) during cross examination?

Suppose a defendant testifies at a criminal trial and is advised beforehand that the prosecution has a right to cross examine him. Suppose the defendant answers all of his lawyer's questions on direct ...
Greg Schmit's user avatar
1 vote
2 answers
308 views

Are authorities allowed to use technology to read your mind? [closed]

If a technology that reads minds existed, would it be legal for authorities in the United States to use that technology to extract incriminating information from a defendant's mind against their will? ...
Nick Alger's user avatar
-3 votes
1 answer
116 views

Call from detective [closed]

say hypothetically someone committed a the crime of stealing a public sign and being publicly intoxicated under the age of 21.. The next day a detective calls asking to talk in person and says they &...
user55665484375's user avatar
27 votes
3 answers
8k views

Why is knowledge inside one's head considered privileged information but knowledge written on a piece of paper is not?

At least in the US, one can refuse to reveal information contained inside one's head by pleading the Fifth Amendment. However, the same protections don't apply to papers (or computer files) with ...
JonathanReez's user avatar
  • 4,373
22 votes
6 answers
7k views

What's stopping someone from saying "I don't remember"?

There are (at least) two problems possibly stemming from a person testifying in court: If they tell the truth, the testimony may have negative consequences they potentially don't like (which is the ...
user0306's user avatar
  • 1,651
18 votes
1 answer
3k views

Can an attorney plead the 5th if attorney-client privilege is pierced?

In the investigation related to Mar-a-Lago, the Justice Department is seeking to pierce attorney-client privilege relating to several bits of testimony and discovery items they're seeking from Trump's ...
Pyrotechnical's user avatar
2 votes
2 answers
572 views

When you plead the 5th and a Judge asks you questions about it, is that conversation considered privileged?

If you invoke the right to not self-incriminate when testifying and the judge asks you questions in regards to whether you fear of incriminating yourself is reasonable. Is that conversation considered ...
Neil Meyer's user avatar
  • 4,809
1 vote
2 answers
317 views

If the police ask you a question, what response can you make that can't be used as evidence against you?

For one reason or another, a police officer has just asked you a question, and you've wisely decided not to provide any response that could be used against you in court. What can you say or do that ...
Tanner Swett's user avatar
14 votes
7 answers
6k views

Is the saying that "cops can use anything you say against you" overstated or understated?

Is everything one says to a cop in the course of an enquiry really admissable as evidence against them? Even if they deny allegations? Why is that?
Statistics's user avatar
0 votes
1 answer
77 views

Can someone be prosecuted for perjury after being given immunity on the grounds that they falsely pleaded the fifth?

Let's say that person A is being questioned in court and is asked where they were on the night of April 1st. Person A pleads the fifth, is given immunity, and is compelled to testify. Upon person A ...
SlowlySwift's user avatar
0 votes
1 answer
107 views

How is Biden’s lawyers turning the documents over not a material breach of client-attorney confidentiality and a violation of the 5th, 6th Amendments?

If a client confessed to plans, in-going activity or intent to commit a crime, an attorney may disengage. I would argue imposing a duty on an attorney to disclose their reasons if it requires court ...
Raiden Snaker's user avatar
1 vote
2 answers
174 views

Defendant's Cherry-Picking

In Discovery, "the prosecutor is obligated to provide to the defendant any information that is exculpatory or potentially exculpatory". I am looking for cases where the defendant, on the ...
bobuhito's user avatar
  • 981
13 votes
1 answer
7k views

Can a foreigner invoke the fifth amendment?

Bob is a non-US citizen and is visiting the USA on a tourist visa. During his visit, he broke a US law. Law enforcement is unaware of that crime. While breaking the law, he is also a witness to some ...
Olivier Grégoire's user avatar
3 votes
1 answer
1k views

Can a witness refuse to answer a question in a civil proceeding if it would incriminate her on a unrelated criminal matter?

Basically the title. I saw on a lawyer drama that a witness was compelled to answer because it was not a criminal case. But if the truthful answer uncovers a criminal matter that would incriminate the ...
lvella's user avatar
  • 181
5 votes
2 answers
244 views

How are sanctions on individuals consistent with the 5th Amendment?

There is a lot in the news these days about ultra-wealthy Russians being sanctioned, their assets frozen, and their private jets and boats seized. I'm curious about the constitutional justification of ...
Alex's user avatar
  • 59
3 votes
2 answers
306 views

Are defendants legally obliged to provide all culpatory evidence to prosecution?

There is a similar question that doesn't address this one. The question here is whether or not all evidence requested by prosecution must be provided by the defense? If the defense plans on only using ...
haleonj's user avatar
  • 361
15 votes
3 answers
4k views

Can evidence a person gives to aid an investigation then be used to prosecute that person for an unrelated crime?

Consider the following scenario: a person consents to giving some evidence to aid the investigation or prosecution of a criminal,with the reasonable, good-faith assumption that the use of that ...
DerekG's user avatar
  • 389
3 votes
2 answers
216 views

Legality of IRS requiring taxpayers to swear to statements

The IRS requires taxpayers to swear under "penalties of perjury" to their statements and figures given concerning their income. Since obviously this constitutes a potential incrimination, it ...
Cicero's user avatar
  • 6,900
9 votes
2 answers
2k views

Can you plead the 5th in a civil case?

There seems to be the idea that the right not to self-incriminate does not apply to civil cases. Is that true?
Neil Meyer's user avatar
  • 4,809
5 votes
1 answer
156 views

How does Miranda rights work in regards to sign-language?

If a person were to be interviewed by police and he responded in sign-language. What he said turn out to be false. In court his lawyer argued what he said could not be used against him because he did ...
Neil Meyer's user avatar
  • 4,809
4 votes
1 answer
295 views

Can your silence be used against you?

Miranda rights say you have the right to remain silent and that anything you say can be used against you. My question is, can the exercise of this right be used against you at a trial? It seems that ...
Neil Meyer's user avatar
  • 4,809
2 votes
1 answer
167 views

Fifth Amendment privileges v. Sixth Amendment privileges in criminal trials

I'm quite confident that all users on Law StackExchange are well acquainted with the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution, which confers the privilege against self-incrimination upon witnesses as well ...
Tolga Eskici's user avatar
2 votes
2 answers
308 views

How does a witness get an attorney?

Someone who was with George Floyd the day he was killed pleaded the Fifth (source). The Hennepin County Public Defender's Office filed the notice on behalf of Morries Hall, who was sitting in the ...
Azor Ahai -him-'s user avatar
13 votes
4 answers
3k views

Alternatives to pleading the 5th that also offers protection

I watched a old video (Don't talk to Police) that popped up while looking up information related to cyber forensics and false positives. I gathered the following points: You can't talk your way out ...
jtlindsey's user avatar
  • 245
9 votes
4 answers
3k views

Alternative systems without the Right to Remain Silent

As I understand it, the "Right to Remain Silent" errs on the side of innocence in the USA justice system. Jurors are usually supposed to rule as if the defendant testified in the manner ...
bobuhito's user avatar
  • 981
2 votes
1 answer
741 views

Could I create doubt of a crime by having multuple people suggest, but not actually claim, that they were the murderer?

Let's say hypothetically I'm a member of some gang and just killed a member of a rival gang. I've been accused of murder and taken to trail. My fellow gang members want to help me get off, but not ...
dsollen's user avatar
  • 8,410
12 votes
2 answers
3k views

Can I surprise the prosecution with an alibi defense at trial?

Let's say I've been accused of a murder. Throughout the investigation I've plead the Fifth as to where I was when the crime happened. Eventually I'm put on trial, still pleading the fifth as to my ...
dsollen's user avatar
  • 8,410
2 votes
3 answers
302 views

Is the United States federal income tax an indirect tax under the 5th amendment?

I'm no American citizen, so I don't know that much about all the ins and outs of the Constitution. I've been watching a movie where one of the characters called the federal income tax "...
Zhiltsoff Igor's user avatar
11 votes
2 answers
2k views

Arizona law requires you to admit to carrying a firearm. Would that be admissible evidence?

This question describes an Arizona law which requires a person stopped by the police to answer honestly when asked if they have a concealed deadly weapon. Suppose that someone in Arizona is carrying ...
Paul Johnson's user avatar
  • 13.2k
0 votes
5 answers
273 views

Lawyer-approved statement to say to the police to unequivocally retain all rights

I understand that I have the right to remain silent, and that I shouldn't need to explicitly say that in order for my rights to be in effect. But we don't live in a perfect world. And should we end up ...
Dave C's user avatar
  • 127
0 votes
1 answer
309 views

Does the U.S. Fifth Amendment prevent one from being tried again for the same crime?

I have a question about the Fifth Amendment. Imagine I committed a crime but I was acquitted at trial. After some time, some new evidence came up showing that I did do it. Does the Fifth Amendment say ...
Yovel's user avatar
  • 21
1 vote
3 answers
523 views

What legal recourse do we have against Clearview AI's collection of our personal data and terrifying privacy policy?

TL;DR: how do we get the data this company collected on us without also giving them our government-issued IDs that they could potentially keep and tie to our "profiles"? A week ago (January ...
Chris Cirefice's user avatar
21 votes
2 answers
6k views

What kinds of sanctions would be applied if you wrongly invoked the Fifth Amendment?

Under the Fifth Amendment, one might say at a hearing, "I refuse to answer on the grounds that it would incriminate me." Suppose the subject matter were embarrassing, but not necessarily criminal. ...
Libra's user avatar
  • 6,448
5 votes
1 answer
581 views

Would a confession obtained via Wonder Woman's Magic Lasso be admissible in US court, or any court?

There's a scene in Justice League (the movie from 2017) where a policewoman is taking down the stories of three criminals who are wrapped in in Wonder Woman's magic Lasso. The Lasso does a couple of ...
GridAlien's user avatar
  • 1,624
1 vote
2 answers
267 views

What happens if a person has evidence that an accused party is innocent, but to give that evidence would be self-incriminatory?

Suppose that Person A is accused of a crime. Person B (unbeknownst to anybody but themselves) actually committed the crime. Suppose further that Person B is called as a witness in the case of Person A....
Alex's user avatar
  • 311
28 votes
3 answers
11k views

USA: Can a witness take the 5th to avoid perjury?

Lawyer Alice is questioning witness Bob. Bob is not on trial, and no one has accused him of a crime. Alice demands Bob answer a particular question with either a "Yes" or a "no." Bob believes that ...
GridAlien's user avatar
  • 1,624
5 votes
4 answers
820 views

Claiming self-defense and refusing to self-incriminate at the same time

Bob shoots Rob dead. Noone saw what actually happened, no video footage, nothing. Bob does not deny shooting Rob but claims it was self-defense. He does not go into details — invoking his right not to ...
Greendrake's user avatar
  • 27.4k
2 votes
3 answers
1k views

What do you do when the truth is something that can be proven false beyond a reasonable doubt?

Suppose you firmly believe something to be true but you know that it can be proven false beyond a reasonable doubt. This can happen if, for example, you witnessed something that is incredibly unusual. ...
David Schwartz's user avatar
3 votes
2 answers
331 views

Can defense request findings of fact before resting?

Hypothetical scenario: A victim is identified with documented injuries consistent with having been struck with a weapon. The police find and charge a person (now "Defendant") that they claim ...
feetwet's user avatar
  • 21.8k
5 votes
2 answers
2k views

Does the 5th Amendment only apply to federal government

The 5th Amendment of the Constitution of the United States says No person shall be held to answer for a... crime, unless on a presentment or indictment of a Grand Jury..., nor be deprived of life, ...
ElliotThomas's user avatar
1 vote
0 answers
63 views

Can reporting illegal income be used as incriminating evidence? [duplicate]

As we all know, in the United States it is required to report and pay taxes on income obtained illegally. Can the fact that this income is mentioned on a person's tax return be used as evidence that ...
Daniel's user avatar
  • 209
5 votes
3 answers
253 views

Suspending White House hard pass & preliminary injunction

Jim Acosta was asked by the Secret Service to surrender a White House hard pass as the result of an altercation in a press event. The White House press secretary explained that it being suspended ...
Burt_Harris's user avatar
  • 1,789
53 votes
3 answers
8k views

How does the mandate to report income from illegal activities in the US jibe with the Fifth Amendment?

Al Capone was famously taken down for tax evasion for not reporting income from his illegal activities. If someone were to report the income from illegal activities like a marijuana dispensary or a ...
A. K.'s user avatar
  • 2,314
6 votes
5 answers
839 views

Suppose an effective truth serum existed. Could defendants in the following situations have their confessions ruled inadmissable?

Suppose a "Hollywood style" truth serum existed, whereby if a person is given the serum, that person is compelled to truthfully answer any question put to them. The following facts are true in all of ...
Steve V.'s user avatar
  • 686
1 vote
2 answers
1k views

Immunity to prosecution vs multiple jurisdiction

Consider the following scenario: Witness (not defendant) asked to testify at a civil case at a state court. Witness takes the fifth out of nowhere, that is at a completely unexpected place in ...
Joshua's user avatar
  • 225
7 votes
1 answer
2k views

Can you be legally compelled to disclose your password in a criminal investigation? [duplicate]

Let's say you use encryption on your computer, and you've been arrested. The police believe there is evidence on your computer, and have seized the computer via a warrant. The police cannot extract ...
user avatar
1 vote
2 answers
781 views

What are the 5th Amendment Rights of Minor Students with respect to School Resource Officers?

I am wondering how to teach my children what Professor James Duane of Regent University advises: Don't Talk to the Police. Then I considered that in reaction to school shootings, my local school ...
emory's user avatar
  • 879