The Bylaws state that a quorum is 25% of active members (130 x .25 = 33). A specific vote requires 75% of the quorum in order to pass (33 x .75 = 25). My question is, if 100 people are in attendance, and the quorum threshold is only 33, does the 75% of the quorum (25) vote requirement cause the vote to be affirmed even though 75 people might vote against the item?

  • Does this group specify Roberts Rules of Order as its parliamentary manual, or some other manual, or make no specification? – David Siegel Feb 14 '19 at 23:16
  • 2
    Do the bylaws say "yes vote of 75% of the quorum is required for a motion to pass", or does it say "75% of the (valid) votes cast must be affirmative for a motion to pass". If the former, then yes (strange but not inconceivable). You should give us the verbatim text. – user6726 Feb 15 '19 at 1:13
  • Here are the excerpts from the Bylaws for defining the quorum and "75% of quorum" stipulation. – Jeff Feb 15 '19 at 20:16
  • Roberts Rules is the parliamentary manual. Here are the excerpts from the Bylaws for defining the quorum and "75% of quorum" stipulation. "QUORUMS - A quorum shall consist of 25% of the persons who meet the requirements of active membership. Members who are homebound, hospitalized, or in care facilities shall not count against the quorum requirement." "An affirmative vote of 75% of the Church Membership quorum is required to call the proposed candidate as Senior Pastor. – Jeff Feb 15 '19 at 20:24

It depends on what manual of parlimentary procedure is used by the group if any (see comment). But in general i would take the 25 vote requirement to be a floor, but that a majority of those voting, however many they are, must vote in favor for a measure to pass. If that majority is less than 25 votes, it still doesn't pass due to this 75% of a quorum requirement.



Presumably, the 75% of the quorum requirement is an additional requirement for the particular motion over and above the requirement that all motions must be carried by a simple majority of members present and able to vote. So it needs to pass both thresholds.

For your example, 33-50 members present, the threshold is 25 - the 75% of the quorum requirement. For 51+ members present the threshold is 50% of the members present rounded up - the simple majority requirement.

This is an unusual provision and it is likely that the drafters meant 75% of members present and eligible to vote which is much more typical. However, it is unambiguous and workable as written.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.