0

In country A, it's illegal to say something to a person (it's considered a severe insult that is punished with jail)

User 1 is using Twitter in country B, where such law doesnt exist, and he is a citizen of country A, and he says something about another user 2 (in country A) where such thing said it's illegal .

Twitter is hosted in country C.

Is User 1 committing a crime? Or the law from country A doesnt apply to him because he's in another country and the service he is using is in a third country?

BTW, I couldnt come up with a better title. If you can come up with a more descriptive title, please edit it.

1

Yes, user1 is committing a crime - but this is not surprising, almost everyone commits crimes every day.

What you are most likely talking about are "Lèse majesté" laws.

The question of jurisdiction is really a matter of "what does the jurisdiction in question say" and "how can they enforce this"? If you are not committing an offense in country B, it is unlikely country A will be able to extradite you, so unless you go back to country A they can't do much.

The worst Twitter can do is ban you if they are successfully pressured to by Country A or Country C.

Maybe anecdotally helpful - One of the places this is most strictly enforced (outside, perhaps, North Korea), is Thailand. It is noteworthy that a US diplomat was investigated for breaching this law, but as a diplomat he could not be punished - because he is not subject to Thai law, even in Thailand - "Thediplomat.com" reported : "Davies enjoys diplomatic immunity, so even if he is found guilty of lèse majesté, he will not be tried and punished under Thai law. However, Thai authorities have hinted that the investigation will continue and that Davies could be subject to some kind of reprimand from the government. Still, it remains unclear what such a reprimand would entail."

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.