A girl that works for a major retail chain, is left unable to lift her arm above her head after being asked to lift a 180lb box. When trying to perform this task her shoulder "popped".

She has requested to file an injury report with the company but was ask not to because:

It's a lot of paperwork.


the location is nearing a year without any injuries being doctor level.

  • Do Florida labor laws protect employees in such cases?

  • Can she seek any kind of legal action if the company refuses to pay her medical bills?

1 Answer 1


You should consult this web page from the Florida government. First, you are expected to report the injury to the employer within 30 days, and if you do not, your claim may be denied. You have actually done that (they have actual knowledge of the injury so a future petition is not barred by the 30 day rule). Then within 7 days they are to report the injury to their insurance company. They acknowledge that employers may refuse to report injuries, and clarify that the employee has a right to report the injury to the insurance company (they offer assistance in doing that). Your medical expenses would be covered. There is also a provision that you can get compensation for lost time.

It is against the law for them to fire you for filing a claim or attempting to file a claim ("No employer shall discharge, threaten to discharge, intimidate, or coerce any employee by reason of such employee’s valid claim for compensation or attempt to claim compensation under the Workers’ Compensation Law").

Regardless of the effect on the location's record of reported accidents or the amount of paperwork involved, it is not obviously in the interest of an employee to forgo their rights to compensation. The employee's attorney can advise the employee whether the company's alternative offer is advantageous. If one does not take action (notifying the insurance company for example), eventually they will have waived your rights for compensation.

Supposing that the employee files a report with the insurance company, and the company then fires her in retaliation. This would not involve any unemployment compensation. There is no provision under the law for the state to litigate on her behalf, although the attorney general might file a class action suit if the company is engaged in widespread illegal terminations. So it would fall on the employee to litigate the matter: retaliation for filing a workman's comp claim is one of the recognized grounds for a wrongful termination suit. There are numerous attorneys who may take such a case on a contingency basis (it would depend on the actual details, to be discussed with the attorney).

  • She didn't report it because she didn't file a written report as per the company policy so they would likely deny it.
    – Putvi
    Apr 6, 2019 at 17:04
  • @Putvi She tried to file the report and was told not to. Furthermore, Florida law according to this answer (and the page linked) states that she has 30 days, not 24 hours as per the company policy, before her rights are waived, and Im having her file the report this morning (within 24 hours of the incident)
    – J.Todd
    Apr 6, 2019 at 17:57
  • As per my comment above, she's being harassed and yelled at by management for demanding to file the report again this morning. I've told her to file it anyway and that they cant fire her for reporting an injury. Let's say they do fire her though, knowing litigation would be too expensive for her, how does that work? Can she get workers comp due to being fired wrongfully and the state potentially takes legal action against the company for costing the state worker compensation that the company illegally initiated?
    – J.Todd
    Apr 6, 2019 at 18:00
  • Related: law.stackexchange.com/questions/38878/…
    – J.Todd
    Apr 7, 2019 at 0:34

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .